Skip to content

What democrats should do to stop Trump’s SCOTUS pick

by Karthika Cohen

Donald Trump has selected conservative federal appeals court judge Amy Coney Barrett as his pick to replace Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the Supreme Court. Barrett, a darling of the religious right, comes with strong conservative credentials on issues such as gun rights, immigration, and abortion.

Republicans are poised to start her confirmation hearing on October 12th, a process that will no doubt energize their political base in the heat of an election campaign.

Mitch McConnell has already vowed that the Senate will vote on Trump’s nominee.  Yes – this is the same McConnell that famously (or infamously, depending on your viewpoint) refused to hold a hearing for President Barack Obama’s pick for the Supreme Court in 2016 because it was “an election year”.

What was too imprudent for McConnell nine months before the presidential election in 2016 can now apparently be done in less than six weeks. Oh what a difference four years makes, what a difference a Republican in the White House makes.

We don’t yet know if McConnell has the number of votes needed to get a nomination through. There are 53 republicans in the Senate, of which two (Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski) have already said they are not in favor of filling the vacancy until after the election. For democrats to win this fight, they will need two more Republicans on their side. Mitt Romney disappointed the entire Democratic establishment by declaring that he will consider and vote on the president’s nominee.

Even with McConnell’s persistence, it may be hard to get a confirmation vote— a process that typically takes a few months—before the election. Democrats will no doubt do everything in their power to slow things down. In addition, there are Republicans in vulnerable races across the country who would rather be campaigning in their home states than sticking around in Washington for a nomination vote.

So what can democrats do to stop a nomination?

They could bring the Senate to a halt, but this would also derail a short-term spending measure to keep the government open and possible legislation to address the COVID-19 crisis. Senate Democrats can insist on a role-call vote to ensure a quorum (the Senate usually operates on the presumption that 51 members are present, but this can be questioned, forcing a role call), which can take up a lot of time. They can refuse unanimous consent forcing debate and votes on even routine matters that typically proceed without objection – wasting a lot of the Senate’s precious time. There are also options to delay committees, such as the “two-hour rule” that Chuck Schumer already invoked last week.

Some have even suggested moving to impeach a Trump administration official (a perfect candidate would be Attorney General Bill Barr), which would force the Senate to receive articles of impeachment and hold a trial – again, taking a lot of time away from a possible nomination and confirmation.

Procedural obstruction and shutting down the government would at least slow down—if not halt—McConnell. But are the Democrats willing to even try?

Both Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi have indicated that they have no intention of bringing the House and Senate to a halt over a Supreme Court pick. Democrats need to stop surrendering to the Republicans on every major fight. Using political gamesmanship and procedural loopholes to keep Ginsberg’s seat open until after the election may prove to be much more critical in the long term than other items on Congress’s limited agenda.

The Supreme Court fight is more than just a political fight – it has real world ramifications that regular people need to be deeply concerned about. Allowing a 6-3 conservative majority on the Court could have implications for voting rights, environmental regulations, gun laws, abortion rights, LGBT rights, and the Affordable Care Act, and even this very Election.

And every democrat (and even republicans who believe at least a little bit in fairness) need to call on their Senators to make sure that they hold this Supreme Court vacancy open until after the Election. Start with Pat Toomey.